Is an
argument that girls who aren't working in sweatshops would be sold to prostitution
actually a moral argument? Likewise, is a few more pennies per day are a better
wage than other jobs in developing countries better than the other
opportunities a reason to morally accept sweatshops? On a day to day level for
the people abject to these issues, these arguments may very well hold true. I
am not objecting to that nor am I comfortable or accepting of these
circumstances for other humans and the implications they have for further humans
and our environment. I realize that I will not know what is like to have no
other opportunities other than working in a sweat shop and possibly gaining a
higher status, especially as a woman, rather than working within some family
business with a risk of being sold as a sex slave (not to claim that this is
the case for everywhere around the world, but is, from what I have read, a plausible
experience). However, as someone who is relatively privileged in this world,
who reaps the benefits of this exploitation with the ability to sit in my bed
writing about said exploitations, I cannot be on board with the arguments
raised in that article. Once again, I realize that there are issues within the
system and ways of helping people within said intuitions but I do not morally
condone them when wealthy corporations in developed countries go on deepening
wealth inequalities. This is because, as I have said, I do not accept most arguments
that come from within our current system of colonization and capitalism. I don’t
have the answers, and cannot speak for anyone else, because I can’t tell who
else wants an iPhone (but maybe that’s something we want to democratically decide
on as worth to create?)? However, just because it is difficult to imagine a
system that works counter to the one we are in—one where prostitution or
complete poverty are the only other viable opportunities to sweat shops and
child labor—does not mean that the systems do not need to be themselves
questioned and changed.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.